McCloud is TOO enthusiastic (Rating 3 of 5)
» M. Keogh
As an architect, and a die-hard modernist, I often find the TV show Grand Designs infuriating. Clients either fire their architects early on and have no concept of how to a) design, b) cost-manage or c) run projects on-site, thus build fairly horrendous homes.
There are a few rare gems but more often than not the projects go way over budget and clients decisions are simply baffling. If there is ONE message to anyone thinking of building their own home, be it a chic 2-bed mews or a grand country home...PLEASE PLEASE look at architectural books, see how good architects do things and then decide on what you want.
Find an enthusiastic architect with prior experience and trust them to design a good home.
McCloud often waxes lyrical about fairly mediocre designs, which bugs me. These designs often do not deserve the attention they are given, and a good architect will avoid the high drama that Grand Designs depends upon to make it interesting.
If you are planning a building / extension project, then read this first. (Rating 5 of 5)
» Mr. P. Stewkesbury
I read this book because we're planning an extension, and I found it to be extremely helpful.
Kevin rationalises the emotive process of designing your own dream. He provides loads of tips and many helpful checklists.
More than anything he provides a compelling case for finding good architects for your project and working closely with them - he makes a convincing case to illustrate that their work will effectively cost you nothing.
Grand Designs Review (Rating 4 of 5)
» L. J. Wilson
I am interested in architecture and plan to study it at university - my passion is based upon the dream of building and designing my own home and this book really helped me with ideas and practicalities. There is a lot of writing (which can be a bit boring and repetitive) but there are some great pictures.
Useful volume - well worth reading (Rating 5 of 5)
» Mark N. Bolton
I think the review by D. Lundholm says almost everything that my review of this book would say.
Just a couple of additional observations:
* This is more of a how-to (think about and then build your own home) book than a book of ideas you can directly use. Not a bad thing, there are plenty of other glossy books to get ideas from.
* Related to that, there are no floor-plans for any of the designs referenced. Personally, I would have preferred to see some, but it doesn't really detract from the usefulness of the book.
* It is an engaging and thought-provoking book - certainly well worth buying at half-price!
* My only real gripe is the way the text references pictures of properties that are not adjacent to the text. i.e. reading page 100 you might be referenced to pictures of the building concerned on pages 94 and 115-117.
Overall, highly recommended for both dreamers and those seriously planning to build their own home.
Thoughtful, inspiring book for grand design builders and extenders (Rating 5 of 5)
» D. Lundholm
This is an intelligent, thoughtful book by one of the most articulate commentators on modern architecture and building design. For many UK TV viewers, Kevin McCloud's regular Grand Designs programmes are compelling viewing, illustrating both the practical issues that self-builders and developers face, as well as challenging the motivations that inspire people to create their own homes. This is far from just a "book of the series". It's a guide to building your own home - equally of value for extenders, developers or those thinking about how to improve the design of the space they live in - written in three sections - thinking, dreaming and doing.
Thinking challenges lots of the traps self-builders and remodellers fall into - in a way that engages you and walks you through the process of trying to identify what we want of of our homes. I guess there's a danger post Grand Designs that we all tend to think it's easy to articulate exactly what we want, and what we need, and that programme only engages after the thinking has been done (and it probably doesn't make for great television either, seeing people try to figure this out). But (from personal experience) it's actually the most difficult bit, yet the bit that makes it more (or less) likely that you're going to end up with a house that truly delivers what you hope it will.
Once you kinda know what you want, and you've engaged with an architect (a theme that runs very strongly throughout is to seek professional advice, at every stage), the dreaming section illustrates 5 different approaches to build - from New Urban, New Suburban, New Rural, New Use (eg change of use from industrial to home) and New Life - renovation and repair. Amply illustrated with houses from Grand Designs, and others, you get lots of helpful comments that don't just detail what the owner/architect has done but also explain why it delivers more light, adds more space, gives more connection with the outside. Even if you think you know why you "like" what you see, having it explained in this way helps you identify whether it would work in your planned home.
The final "doing" section is lots of practical "how to move you through the phases - from initial plans, the dreaded planning application, working with drawings, building regulations and how to manage the project and its finances. Well organised, step by step, guidance that I suspect I'm going to refer to again and again.
Throughout, there is plenty of checklisted, "think about this", do this and don't do that, stuff, and there are several hundred illustrations, mainly of homes featured in Grand Designs.
IMHO, it's an opinionated, highly approachable guide, written with clarity, laced with wit and Kevin's laconic observations.
If you like what you've seen on Grand Designs, you enjoy Kevin's style, and you're considering extensions or self-build, I'd recommend this very highly.
If you don't like him, or Grand Designs, he does forewarn you: "You might find the range of my choice [of homes] rather limited. But if you don't like any of them, you probably don't like what I have to say either, and so shouldn't have bought this book in the first place".
(Rating 3 of 5)
(Rating 5 of 5)
(Rating 4 of 5)
